The Religious "Off" Switch


I used to delight in asking my Christian brothers and sisters why they believed the things they said they believed. The most common answer was simply, "That's what I've always been told." That always disturbed me. You could pull a wisdom tooth with a piece of string easier than you could get a straight answer out of most of these people. I decided it was my purpose, indeed my calling, in life to teach the foundations of Christianity to all these people who didn't seem to know why they were even believers in the first place. I wasn't exactly successful.

But I tried for 18 long years to instill a love for God's word in people who claimed to love him wholeheartedly but weren't terribly interested in any of the reasons why. My religion was my life, I was a man of God. I was anointed, Spirit filled, chosen and called for the work of the ministry. I loved the life. I loved the purpose it gave me. I had no desire to question it or ever leave it.

Then one morning I had a stroke.


Oxygen deprivation can do horrible things to your body and your brain. It can kill you (which I obviously avoided), it can maim you, it can make you forget how to walk, it can leave you unable to speak or communicate, it can paralyze you and basically ruin your entire life. In my case, it left me able to move, to speak, and to function, but with the added joy of never ending pain. It cost me my job of 23 years and destroyed any hope of having any kind of retirement. It changed the way I think and the way I feel; I have no emotional reactions to anything except an incredibly intense but fleeting anger. I literally lost the ability to care about anything. Add intense pain that never lets up (for 8 miserable years now) and you have a seriously distorted view of life that you never expected or wanted.

But even stranger than any of that, you discover that your faith which you thought was unshakeable was not only shaken but eliminated entirely. As simply as flicking a light switch but with some profound complications. You soon discover no one believes you or has the slightest idea what you're trying to tell them. Certainly no pastor or holy man has an explanation other than an attack of Satan. I felt that God had abandoned me.

But one thing hadn't changed. I still wanted to know why.

I began reading things I never would have looked at before on the internet (this was 1998.) They would have caused doubt and doubt is something no man of god can allow himself to have or even consider. Doubt destroys faith. It brings guilt and condemnation. It ruins your fellowship with god. Doubt cannot be allowed. But I was already convinced that god tossed me to the dogs and then checked out of my life altogether, I couldn't find him anywhere.

There had to be an explanation and the proverbial test of faith was unsatisfying. Jesus promised to be with me always but apparently he lied or he wasn't talking to me in the first place. So I started reading things; things written by people who were religious but had opposing doctrines to my own. Surprisingly they made sense in some regards even though I never would have considered them before. Gradually, I started moving into the secular realm. Then one day I discovered an atheist blog written by an intelligent young man who had gotten free of Jehovah's Witnesses. I found his deconversion story inspiring and began to seek after others.

A major breakthrough occurred when I found EbonMusings and started reading all his articles. One of them made references to people who had religious alterations caused by brain damage. Several of the case histories he quoted sounded remarkably like what happened to me in one aspect or another. I was amazed that an atheist had such insight into the nature of faith and belief and what sort of physical things could influence it. I began to devour more and more atheistic writings.

When I finally began reading about biblical inconsistencies I knew I had finally found my answer. The bible wasn't the perfect, inerrant word of god that I believed it was. The contradictions weren't there because my understanding was flawed, they were there because the book itself is flawed. Once I was able to accept that, it was no great leap to accept that there is no god, no living Jesus. No wonder I couldn't find him.

I've condensed the hell out of my story because it is extremely complicated and covers several years. I was a true believer, now I'm not. The stroke cut me off from my religion, it severed the emotional and intellectual ties. I stayed away from church and consequently got away from guilt. That right there will free your mind tremendously. I always knew something was wrong with the bible but, like I had been trained, I assumed it was my own lack of understanding. Fortunately I never lost my desire to know why. Studying the writings of people who used reason to escape from Christianity opened my eyes to the truth.

I had a religious "Off" switch. I wonder if you do, too.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

Frank, if you've read my deconversion story it was just like yours. 1) There was a crisis (not like yours, but one just the same), 2)There was new information; and 3) There was a sense of a lack of a loving caring Church. It can happen to anyone...anyone.

Frank said...

My trigger may have been drastic but the results weren't unusual. I had witnessed people leaving the church before and had wondered why no one ever seemed to know why. I then discovered it was because no one ever tried to find out why. Early on someone told me the church frequently abandons its' wounded. What an understatement. It's amazing how many deconversion stories follow this pattern and it's quite remarkable how seriously studying (and questioning) the bible actually can lead you away from Christianity.

Mikayla Starstuff said...

Wow that's a great story. Thanks for sharing that.

Anonymous said...

Religiosity and spirituality involve complex cognitive processes, all of which have an underlying neurobiological basis.

Some neurologists claim that they can induce religious experiences by stimulating specific regions of the brain under experimental conditions.

If this is the case, then the converse must also be true. It follows, then, that the ability to have religious experiences, or to be spiritual, can be, as you say, "switched off," when those parts of the brain underlying such cognitive processes are affected by stroke or are damaged in other ways.

Mojoey said...

Wow – what a great de-conversion story. I’ve been struggling with how to write mine but want to share a piece. I because a Christian on a mountain top in the in the 70s, it was a mystical and powerful moment. It turns out that the mystical was cause by a substance, but that is another story for another day. I was devout. I spent my high school years trying to bring as many people into the fold as possible. I was even going to be a pastor. I was all set to start studying at Biola. I started to doubt things that seemed absurd to me. Basically, I had a very inquisitive mind and never accepted “have faith” when proof would settle a discussion. I met Jim Jones and raised money for his ministry (big negative karma thing) Doubts piled up, time passed. I met my wonderful future wife to be, who also happened to be a non-practicing catholic. I started to question things more. I openly asked many questions of my youth pastor, who thought I was nuts. Then I almost died in an accident. Massive head trauma, coma, hospitalization, memory loss, coordination issues, you name it. It took a year to recover. In that year I started reading, my mind opened to logic, reason, and science. I lost my faith. And once lost – it only got harder to remember why I even thought faith was important. I have no understanding of faith now – the concept baffles me.

I lost all my friends. Every one of them, they were all Christians. Once I turned away, they walked away from our relationships. Even the pastors, they were the worst. It was almost like I was deemed a failure and cast aside. I am not bitter, my life is so much better now that I use my brain.

Vile Blasphemer said...

Ditto, Neurophilosopher.

SuperSkeptic said...

My religious off switch is in the middle of being flipped. For me, it came with therapy -- the realization that I am/was only religious so that I don't disappoint my parents. (Yeah, I know I'm in my 30's.)

The catalyst was the fact that I don't want my kids (2 and 4) raised in a religious environment, and that made me look long and hard at my own beliefs. I might be unwilling to disappoint my parents, but I am more unwilling to put my kids through the torture that I've gone through as an on-and-off Christian.

My deconversion story is (mostly) detailed at super-skeptic.blogspot.com, if anybody's interested.

Frank said...

Wow. I was in the flesh for all those years and never really knew god? I'm shocked. I do find it interesting that I would need to read the works of men in order to get out of the flesh. I would think that god's word as dictated by his spirit would have sufficient power within itself to lead me directly to god without the need of yet another man to explain it to me. Since all of my senses are in the flesh - wait a minute - even my mind is encased in the flesh of my brain! I have to wonder, who appointed you as someone who could discern such a thing? You don't want to be a christian anymore? Obviously you were never really a christian to begin with. Please. Is there a book out there with these simple rebukes spelled out so if they say this you say that?

tn said...

"you just have to plug it into the right mode... the spirit. make your spirit come alive. the flesh, after all, only leads to death."

"Long live the new flesh", anyone?

"they do not know God truly"

Again, another "True Christian" speaks out. We've all heard the No True Scotsman argument before in one form or another. This is a first, though. I swear, comanpalabritas must watch Videodrome way too often.

Anonymous said...

Hello it is still me, "comanpalabritas". my account has changed. I'm back a few months back after reading your replies I had forgotten about this post.
First off, thanks for your input and for reading the post.
My first reply goes to Frank who seems a bit distressed by my implication of living in the flesh all these years. I have to agree with Frank about the fact that we are all encased in the flesh. In fact it is impossible not to be encased in the flesh. Wasn't this Paul's dilemma? The objective of Jesus Christ living IN US is to lead a spiritual life that is contrary to the flesh. THIS IS IMPOSSIBLE unless THROUGH CHRIST.
To see my mind, and my flesh, or "myself" if we want to quit the bible slang, as incapable of being GOOD is the purpose for the death of Christ for me. I no longer live, think, do, ... it is Christ who lives in me. The mistery that has been revealed to us is that is now Christ living IN US - the hope of Glory. as we are His temple.

Until we understand that our flesh is worthless, that our "good deeds" are not good because nothing good can come from our fallen nature, and that our understanding has been blurred... we will be struggling and doing things with our own strength, understanding, and we will never arrive at truth or at GOD.

Sometimes pastors, ministers, good christians, they turn off their "switch" because they never really found God or never experienced the truth of denying their own flesh, their own "goodness", their own actions, in exchange for a greater more pure REALITY which is that of CHRIST living IN THEM.

To this i can already hear yourself trying to justify your needs for pleasure etc, probably saying that to "die to onself" is about sacrifices that we constantly have to make and thus a very unhappy life. However i think this is exactly what turned off your "switch"... and this is why you found "god" so unfulfilling. The fact of trying and doing things on our own strength, trying to be good... trying to live righteously... they are all good intentions but they are things that will only tire us and they are in fact IMPOSSIBLE.

To die to oneself is only possible by surrendering. Not surrendering to your own strength in order to try to be "good", but surrendering to GOD. being able to say "hey yeah, im a human being and i cant do it... so do it through me". This requires faith. and faith, is a gift given to God out of mercy and grace.

There are many people being "good" and they will burn out if they are only following the rules of religion or of they are following their own desires to be a good person.

Christ in us is not about us. it is not even about becoming a "good person". it is about knowing that ONLY CHRIST through us is what is worthy, any other goodness resulting from ourselves is filth.

so no, Frank, i really think that your experience with god was not an experience of you surrendering entirely to Christ. therefore it was you being good on your own strength. ah yes, we all think we have that power... sounds like pride to me.

To Dennis:
The other kind of reasoning there is is the reasoning that comes from "the mind of Christ". also found in Paul's writings. by human reasoning i mean OUR own limited reasoning, the whole 10% of our brain that we think is enough to understand God... when we battle with simple desicions that affect our lives everyday! Humans, us, we, you and i, struggle with breakups, relationships, desicions about what job or not to take, desicions about our children... etc, how do you suggest that with this mind, this human mind that only uses 10% of its capacity, how do you suggest we use it to understand god? My suggestion is we dont. My suggestion is we use our spirit, becasue the word itself is SPIRITUAL and thus, it cannot be understood in the flesh.

and to Drunken Tune:
I don't think there is anything as a "true Christian". i only think there are true believers or not. Clearly Frank, was not a true BELIEVER. for if he believed, he would have known that Christ lived in him...

the good news is.. Christ can live in all of us. IF WE BELIEVE. Then we can quit trying so hard to be "good" ... life becomes simple.

Peace to you ...

Anonymous said...

Yes. So said but true. I am sorry you had a stroke.
How disconcerting to have your whole world turned upside-down.
Yes. If Christians would actually READ their bible, they would be in for a shocker. My faith too at one time was unshakeable. It is amazing how human beings have the capability to work themselves up into thinking something is so real...just crap shoveled down our throats since infancy. You know, I thought when I figured out the great LIE, that I would be balling uncontrollably. My whole world crashing down. But instead, I am just really really pissed off...like when I was 8 and realized that Santa Claus the Tooth Fairy were big lies. I get so mad lately only to chastise myself because there is no God or Jesus as I was raised to believe in them, so I am mad and ranting for no reason....tragedy.