There is a great deal of discussion among Christian apologists over Bayesian “background factors,” which play a significant role in assessing the truth of Christianity in general, the likelihood of the resurrection of Jesus, the probability of miracles, and the problem of evil. But I want to take a good hard look at the most important background factor of all for cognitively assessing the truth of religious faiths—one’s sociological and cultural background.
I’ve investigated my faith from the inside as an insider with the presumption that it was true. Even from an insider’s perspective I couldn’t continue to believe. Now from the outside it makes no sense at all. Christians are on the inside. I am now on the outside. Christians see things from the inside. I see things from the outside. From the inside, it seems true. From the outside, it seems, well, bizarre.
There are many religious faiths from which to choose. How does one actually choose to be on the inside of any of them if from the outside none of them have any plausibility? Unless one is on the inside as an adherent of a particular religious faith one cannot see. But from the outside, the adherents of a different faith seem blind. This reminds me of what Mark Twain said: “The easy confidence with which I know another man’s religion is folly teaches me to suspect that my own is also.” Believers are truly atheists (i.e., nonbelievers) with regard to all other religions but their own. People known as “atheists” just reject one more religion for pretty much the same reasons they rejected the others.
This whole inside/outside perspective is quite a dilemma; it prompts me to propose and argue on behalf of the Outsider Test for Faith, the result of which makes the presumption of skepticism the preferred stance when examining a particular religious faith, including one’s own. My argument is as follows:















