Two Atheists Debate Whether Jesus Died On the Cross

If you're interested in debates like I am, below you can watch an interesting one by two atheists. Yep, that's right, two atheists. Oh, I know that Mary Jo Sharp is a Christian apologist and that Ehteshaam Gulam is a Muslim apologist. But if you listen closely they are using atheist arguments against each other.



I differ with them both here and there in their criticisms of course. And I especially disagree in what they are both trying to establish (i.e., that Jesus survived the cross, per Gulam, and that Jesus bodily arose from the grave, per Mary Jo). But they are as skeptical of each others views as I am of theirs, and hence atheists with respect to them.

My Outsider Test for Faith challenges believers to apply the same level of skepticism to their own faith as they use to critique the faiths of others. Why can't they see this? Why don't they do this?