Mixed Reviews About "God or Godless?" (Co-written with Dr. Randal Rauser)

One reviewer on Amazon said:
I don't know who initiated this book. If it was John, he chose a lightweight opponent, if it was Randal, he took on a fighter two leagues above. 'Winning' is not actually the aim of such discourse, but here, Randal is knocked k.o. in every round. John gives amazingly rich arguments in short space with facts and quotes while Randal is telling silly stories on the intellectual level of an 8 year old. Link.
Another review by pastor Michael Robinson says almost the exact opposite. Check it out for yourselves: God or Godless?: One Atheist. One Christian. Twenty Controversial Questions.