Chapter 1, My Christian Conversion and Deconversion, by John W. Loftus
In this first chapter I’ll tell you my personal story of how I converted to and then deconverted away from the Christian faith. This chapter forms the backdrop for understanding me and why I wrote this book. After all, no one thinks in a vacuum. Who we are, and what we believe, depend to a large extent on the influences that have shaped us. So in this chapter you’ll get to know some of the influences in my life that made me who I am. I could only wish that Christian apologists who write their apologetic books would do the same thing. I want to know what personal experiences they have had and how they interpret them so that I can be able to judge why they believe the things that they do. But they don’t generally do this at all. What we get instead are their arguments as if they came to believe because of them. This is emphatically not how they came to believe. They hardly ever came to believe because they sat down and dispassionately investigated the various religions before choosing one of them. They usually came to believe because of personal experiences. Only later did they come up with their arguments for why they think what they believe is correct.
If there is one thing that can be said for me, it’s that I am a very passionate man. When I focus on something and commit myself to it, I give it my all. My conversion experience was dramatic—so dramatic that it stunned everyone around me. There is no one who knew me during my early years as a Christian who would say I was not on fire for God. I burned with passion for “the Lord.” And for good reason; I believed God turned my life around.
I was born in 1954 and grew up in Ft. Wayne, Indiana, in a Catholic home. I went to parochial school up until the fourth grade. It was in my youth when I heard of God’s love for me, and of several Bible stories. Our family went to church, but we were a nominal churchgoing family, for the most part. I never experienced true faith growing up, but I did learn that whenever I was in need I should call out to God.
I was not always a good boy, being the middle child in a home with three boys separated by two and a half years on both sides of me. I seemed to be in almost every fight in the household, first with my older brother, Tom, and then with my younger brother, Jim. Tom was just too big for Jim to get into many fights with him. But not me! I fought with both of them.
My mother earned a college degree and started teaching elementary school just when I was about to enter the eighth grade. But since neither my mother nor my father would be home when we boys got home from school, they knew I would get into trouble from time to time with my brothers once school was out. So to eliminate the problem, they thought it would be good for everyone if I considered attending Howe Military School, in Howe, Indiana, for eighth grade. My mother’s extra income would help pay for the costs, it would help discipline me, and my two brothers would be okay at home unsupervised.
Howe was a good school, and I learned for the first time that I could do well in school. I just hadn’t applied myself before, for whatever reason. Howe required an hour of silence every night for doing homework, and because of this I received higher grades than ever before, B+s and above. I also had a yearlong math class taught by Mr. Eugene Utz, who actually taught us symbolic logic. Yes, that’s right, symbolic logic! He said it was the new math. Since we didn’t know any better, we thought it was math. I didn’t realize what he had taught us until sometime after graduating from college, primarily because I never thought much about it. Later on in life, I actually found myself teaching logic classes for college students.
I have never claimed to have a higher IQ than others, nor that I was better than others at remembering things—sometimes I lack common sense—but what Mr. Utz gave this young passionate boy was something in addition to his passion. He gave me the intellectual tools to think through arguments. When something is taught at an early age, it can make you different than others simply because others were never exposed to anything else. If I seem to be smart, it’s mainly because of Mr. Eugene Utz, who gave me the tools for thinking at an early age.
I didn’t want to go back to Howe the next year, nor did I have to. But on the first day of school in ninth grade, I found myself walking to school next to a fellow ninth-grader who lit up a cigarette on the way. So in order to be cool, I had one too. It wasn’t long before I was in the wrong crowd. I also began to do poorly in algebra class. I just barely passed with Ds. Somehow it didn’t dawn on me that the reason why was because I hadn’t had eighth-grade math, which would have prepared me for algebra. I just thought it was a higher, more advanced form of math, and I just wasn’t getting it. Plus, when I started hanging around the wrong crowd, I wasn’t interested in school and all of my grades plummeted.
I was a problem teenager. I had several problems my ninth-grade year at Lane Jr. High School. When I advanced to Snider High School the next year, I was kicked out several times for several different offenses. Then came my problems with the law where I spent many weeks in the Wood Youth Center, in Ft. Wayne. I dropped out of school. Most of my law breaking occurred during the time my mother and father were separated and divorced, and they found it hard to corral me in. They eventually remarried. But in the meantime, I was arrested six different times as a juvenile offender for various offenses. I think I just wanted to fit in. I just fit in with the wrong crowd, and I had no life goals at that time.
While I never encountered any skeptics that I could tell, I did find people who told me that God loves me and that Jesus is the one person who could help me through troubled waters. That’s all I ever heard. So it seemed natural that when I was a troubled juvenile, I would reach out to the God of the Bible and find the meaning of these Bible stories for my life. But at that age I had no way to know whether or not the Bible was true. I had never investigated it with a critical mind. I just assumed it was true and so I began reading the Bible uncritically. I thought these were God’s words and that he was speaking directly to me every time I read them. It all just seemed so real.
My life was radically changed. After I accepted Jesus, I attended a youth group during the height of the Jesus Movement in Ft. Wayne, Indiana. It was affiliated with the Calvary Temple Church, and it was Pentecostal in nature. I got heavily involved with several Christian friends, who went street witnessing every Friday and Saturday night on Main Street, where there were a couple of strip joints and one gay bar. We witnessed during a city July 4 celebration, and even after hockey games outside the War Memorial Coliseum. I would even go hitchhiking with the express purpose of witnessing to whoever picked me up. I witnessed to everyone almost all of the time.
In Ft. Wayne in 1973 it became cooler to be a “Jesus Freak” than a druggie. Being Jesus Freaks for us was rebelling against the establishment and the old comforting values of our parents just as much as those who followed Timothy Leary’s escape through drugs. We could look the same, have long hair, wear bell-bottom studded jeans, and we could use the same slang when describing Jesus as “hip” and a “cool dude.” We evangelized with sound bites like “get high on Jesus” and “turn on with Jesus.”
My parents had started to attend Christ’s Church at Georgetown, where Jerry M. Paul was the minister. Jerry eventually baptized me, preached at my ordination, and performed the wedding ceremony for my first marriage. That summer he had Brant Doty Jr. as a youth minister—my youth minister. He was attending Great Lakes Christian College (GLCC) and his dad, Dr. Doty, was one of the professors. He told me that with such a passion for Christ I should consider attending there too, so I did. My parents helped me with tuition. After all, I was no longer getting arrested, and I was no longer doing drugs. While at GLCC my freshman year, I took the GED test and got my high school equivalency degree so I could eventually graduate in 1977.
At that point I began investigating my faith. I saw a book at the bookstore by Josh McDowell called Evidence That Demands a Verdict, and I read it completely through. He offered what some critics said about the Bible, and then he countered those critics with quotes from Christian apologists who argued against them. After reading that book, I thought that Christianity also passed intellectual muster. It could handle the attacks of all of the critics. I thought, “It’s true! Christianity is true!”
I also read a book by Hal Lindsey called The Late Great Planet Earth. It was a popular treatment of end-time Bible predictions along with the events around the world that seemed to confirm that Jesus was going to return to the earth within our generation. Once again, I thought to myself, “It’s true! Christianity is true! Jesus might return any day now.”
A friend told me about Francis Schaeffer’s books, and so I began reading them. I began with True Spirituality, then The God Who Is There, Genesis in Space and Time, Escape from Reason, and also He Is There and He Is Not Silent. With each of his books that I read, my faith was confirmed even more than before. I also read several of C. S. Lewis’s books, especially Mere Christianity, Miracles, and The Problem of Pain. I had every reason to believe, especially since Lewis’s and Schaeffer’s books were philosophical in nature. There was no reason not to believe. Yet again I thought, “It’s true! It’s really true!”
At this stage in my life, I probably had no doubts about my faith at all, and with good reason. I had never encountered anything at all to the contrary. It just all made sense. Later I found out that none of these initial reasons for believing had any real merit to them. Christian philosopher Thomas V. Morris effectively dealt with Francis Schaeffer’s apologetics in his book Francis Schaeffer’s Apologetics: A Critique.1 I learned that the critics of the Bible are right, not Josh McDowell.2 I am also no longer convinced by C. S. Lewis’s arguments.3 Furthermore, Hal Lindsey’s timetable for Jesus’ return has been shown to be wrong. Jesus has not returned to earth. Failed predictions of Jesus’ return have become such an embarrassment for Christians that there is now a movement to embrace Preterism, which is the belief that Jesus returned to earth to reign from Jerusalem in a spiritual sense around 70 CE. I’ve concluded that I believed in the Christian faith for initial reasons that were just inadequate—reasons that I have subsequently come to reject. I just did not have the ability to think through the intellectual foundations for my faith at such a time in my life. I believed what was presented to me because that’s all I knew to believe.
Later when I was in the ministry, I visited Israel, the “Holy Land,” in 1989. I was one of nine ministers who went to Israel from Indiana on a journey paid for by the Knights Templar organization in Angola. In a devotional written for the local Herald Republican newspaper (March 8, 1989), I shared what I had learned:
The stories of the beginnings of Christianity have a historical connectedness to them when contrasted with the eastern religion stories. In Christianity God reveals to man through actual historical events real answers that can be satisfying like nothing else can. For instance, Christ’s claim to be “the Way, the Truth and the Life” (John 14:6) has a real historical basis in actual time, and actual places of which I visited. I visited Bethlehem where Jesus was born. I visited Nazareth where Jesus grew up. I touched the Jordan River where he was baptized. I visited an ancient Jewish synagogue in Capernaum where Jesus had surely preached. I walked in and around Jerusalem where he ministered. I stood in the Garden of Gethsemane where Jesus prayed, “Not my will but thine be done.” I stood on the very stones Jesus walked on the night he was betrayed. I stood in the very area where Jesus was crucified, and I visited the empty tomb from which he arose from the dead. I also stood on the Mount of Olives where he ascended into heaven.
There is such a close historical connectedness to the Christian faith that one is extremely hard pressed to deny Jesus’ claim to be our only Savior without also denying early first-century Jewish history. Its faith claims are also claims about a history that was checked by first-century people of that day. Since it is impossible to deny such a historical setting for my faith, it becomes extremely difficult to deny the claims of the Christian faith. Christ is the Way, the Truth and Life—truly!
Five years after I wrote the words above, I would find myself in the throes of doubt. Some of the seeds for my doubt had already been unwittingly sown at Lincoln Christian Seminary (LCS). While there I took a class with Dr. James D. Strauss, a professor with a great deal of understanding and a passion for learning. This man lit me up like a firecracker. He was what I was looking for. Following his example, I became passionate for Christian studies and for defending my faith from all intellectual attacks. However, he also set me on the intellectual path that would eventually lead me away from the faith. As I’ll explain later, he drummed into his students the perfectly reasonable Christian idea that “all truth is God’s truth”—that all truth, whether considered sacred or secular, comes from God. Ultimately, this idea is damaging to the Christian faith.
After graduating from LCS, I wrote an article called “A Christian Defense of the Gospel in a Twentieth Century Land,”4 and later I wrote a devotional for the local Herald Republican newspaper (August 10, 1989) summing up and elaborating on it. I’ll quote from it extensively here:
Can you prove that God exists? When asked that question what do you say? In answer to the question, you couldn’t say that you believe God exists because the Bible says so. Belief in the Bible as truth only comes after one believes in God. Nor could you say that you believe because God answers your prayers. To the unbeliever this is circumstantial evidence. Nor could you say that you believe because your parents have taught you to believe. What if they’re wrong? Nor could you offer the fact that God changed your life as proof that God exists. Perhaps you’re deluded as to the source of the change?
You might want to argue that biblical miracles prove God exists. Here the burden of proof is yours to show that such events really occurred. Yet, for someone who doesn’t already believe in God, miraculous events cannot occur. Of course, the miracle of the resurrection of Christ is a powerful testimony for the existence of a God who raises the dead, but is it proof?
What about fulfilled prophecy in the Bible? We would first need to show that the prophecy was written before the prophesied event actually occurred. Even if it was, then we’d have to show that it wasn’t just a lucky guess. The many prophecies concerning Jesus as the Messiah in the Old Testament, taken together, serve as a powerful testimony to a God who sees the future, but is it proof?
I think I can prove that God exists. Does that surprise you? But before I can attempt that feat, I have to know what standard of proof you are looking for. Scientists cannot prove with certainty that the sun will rise tomorrow, only that it has risen in the past. Neither can they prove with certainty that we have existed for more than one day, because every argument used to show this could be a pre-programmed memory in you. There is no proof that other minds than our own exist with whom we can converse, because it could all be in our heads. Nor could you prove that you exist as you appear to exist, rather than being brains in some future mad-scientist’s vat who is causing you to experience the life you once lived all over again. Isn’t that a scary thought? Now it is reasonable to believe the sun will rise tomorrow, that other minds exist, and that we have existed as we appear to have existed, even if these things are not subject to proof talk.
In the last few centuries philosophers asked theologians to prove that God exists with a certainty that is simply not possible to attain in any field of learning, as witnessed above. Yet, because God’s existence couldn’t be proved by this impossible standard, people grew to believe that God’s existence couldn’t be supported by reason. Of course, this does not follow. For if it’s reasonable to believe we are who we experience ourselves to be without proof, then it can be reasonable to believe God exists without the same kinds of proof demands.
I can prove God exists then, only if we mean proved according to the same standards that allow us to believe we are who we experience ourselves to be. Unfortunately, to offer a proof of something doesn’t mean that it’s going to convince others. Most of us could offer proof that the earth is round, but there will always be people who remain unconvinced, as seen by those in the Flat Earth Society.
God’s existence can be shown to be reasonable by examining consistent sets of answers to questions concerning the basic makeup of the world and man, called “world-views”—there are seven of them. If reasonableness is the standard, the Christian set of answers wins hands down. Christianity makes possible the standard of reasonableness without which modern science would never have arisen. Christian theism is more reasonable than any other total world-view system.
Pretty confident wasn’t I? That was all to change in a few years.
Why I Changed My Mind: My Deconversion
As I share my experiences in what follows, keep in mind that I don’t speak for all skeptics. This is my life, not theirs. The experiences I’ve had are not typical of why people leave the Christian faith. Some former believers have rejected their faith based upon the evidence itself. My initial arguments for rejecting the Christian faith are not the same ones that others have had. Former Christians have left the faith for a wide variety of reasons since there are so many problems with the Christian faith.
For me there were three major circumstances that happened in my life that changed my thinking. They all happened in the space of about five years, from 1991 to1996. These things are associated with three people: Larry, Jeff, and a woman I’ll call Linda. It was Linda who brought a major crisis in my life. Larry brought new information in my life. Jeff took away my sense of a loving Christian community. These are the three things that changed my thinking: a major crisis, plus new information that caused me to see things differently, minus a sense of a loving, caring, Christian community. In the midst of these things, I felt rejected by the Church of Christ in my local area. For me it was an assault of major proportions that, if I still believed in the devil, I would say was orchestrated by the legions of hell.
LINDA
I was the founding president of a shelter for the homeless in Angola, Indiana, where I ministered. It was devoted to giving temporary shelter to people in need. I worked day by day with Linda, the executive director. She practically idolized me. She did everything I said to do, and she would call me daily to ask for help in dealing with various situations that came up from the running of the shelter, along with her own personal issues. I was also having problems with my marriage at the time, and Linda made herself available to me. I succumbed and had an affair with her.
There’s so much more I’d like to say about this, but few people would believe me. As a former stripper in her younger days, she had it in for preachers, and she took out her wrath on me. Perhaps because I was a moral crusader in town and stood against abortion and X-rated video rentals, she chose to humiliate me. Suffice it to say there are some women out there who, akin to Potipher’s wife in the Bible, find it challenging to see if they can sack a minister, and she did.
How many sermons have you heard about Potipher’s seductress wife where preachers wonder aloud if many men could’ve overcome the temptation to sleep with her as she continually made herself available to Joseph (Gen. 39:6–20)? In order to bolster our confidence in Joseph’s faith, they conclude not many men would’ve overcome this temptation. But when someone like me actually does succumb to such a temptation, even if it wasn’t exactly the same, these preachers are quick to condemn me. There are mitigating factors here, even if I did do wrong. And I did do wrong. But until you experience something like this, you will never understand. This lack of understanding doubles my pain.
As far as the affair itself goes, ethicist Richard Taylor wrote a book called Having Love Affairs in which he discussed whose fault it is when there is an affair. Sometimes a married couple mostly ends up sharing the same house and children with each other. I am not excusing myself here, since it takes two, but as he explains, there may be more to it:
Though a wife may be ever so dutiful, faultless, and virtuous in every skill required for the making of a home, if she lacks passion, then in a very real sense she already is without a husband, or he, at least, is without a wife. Similarly, a husband who is preoccupied with himself and his work, who is oblivious to the needs of his wife and insensitive to her vanities, who takes for granted her unique talents and who goes about his business more or less as though she did not exist, has already withdrawn as a husband, except in name. . . . What must be remembered by those persons who wish to condemn adultery is that the primary vow of marriage is to love, and that vow is not fulfilled by the kind of endless busyness exemplified in the industrious and ever generous husband or the dedicated homemaking wife. . . . What has to be stressed is that the first infidelity may or may not have been committed by the one who is having an affair. The first and ultimate infidelity is to withhold the love that was promised, and which was originally represented as the reason for marriage to begin with.”5
But there is more. After only a few months I finally decided I could no longer reconcile the affair with my faith or my family life. So I told Linda that it was over. Well, William Congreve is right, “hell has no fury like a woman scorned.” She went off in a rampage and told the board of directors at the shelter that I had raped her. She went to the prosecutor with my former associate minister and tried to press charges against me, too. They were all lies. No charges were brought against me, thankfully. I thought everyone had heard of her accusations and that most people believed her. I received a phone call from someone who threatened my life, and it sounded like he would kill me. One man for whom I had a great amount of respect had heard her accusations. I said to him, “You don’t believe her, do you?” He replied, “John, I don’t know what to believe.” This really hurt.
I was supposed to be smarter and better than that, or so I thought. How could I have done this? How could I have an affair with her and sin like that against my God and against my family? How could I allow my Christian reputation to be sullied by claims that I had raped her? The biggest question of all was why God tested me by allowing her to come into my life when she did—if he knew in advance I would fail the test. All of this devastated me: my sin, the strange mitigating factors, the Christian people who wouldn’t forgive me even though I repented of the sin of adultery, the false accusation of rape, and God not seeming to care about his wayward soldier. I do thank my ex-wife, Kathy, for forgiving me and for standing by me during this dark period in my life. She understood.
[Edit: What I'm describing were events that happened over 35 years ago when I was still a Christian and never repeated again in two subsequent marriages. The whole reason people know of these events is because I have been honest in writing about them. I was honest about something I did that was bad. So maybe, just maybe, readers should consider that I’m honest in describing why I left the Christian faith.]
LARRY
While I was still feeling the devastation from Linda, I carried on a correspondence debate with my cousin Larry, who was at that time a lieutenant in the United States Air Force and a professor of biochemistry at a base in Colorado. As far as I know he is a believer of some kind. I handed him a book arguing for creation over evolution and asked him to look at it and let me know what he thought of it. After several months, he wrote me a letter of more than thirty pages and included it with a big box full of scientific articles and books on the subject. Some of them were much too technical for me to understand, but I tried to read them. While he didn’t convince me of much at the time, he did convince me of one solid truth. When it came to the age of the universe I could trust what science tells us, and it was undeniable that the universe is about 13.7 billion years old. Prior to this I had only read in the area of the philosophy of science and not the writings of scientists who worked on solving these kinds of problems. At the time, I held to concordism, or the day-age interpretation of Genesis 1 (which I criticize in chapter 15 of this volume). This is the view that each day of Genesis represented and unspecified sequential period of time. A day in Genesis could be billions of years, millions of years, or a thousand years. The duration of a given day in Genesis need not be the same as the duration of the other days. I didn’t have a strong opinion on this because I had not yet studied the scientific evidence. But the evidence Larry sent was eye opening to me. Scientists really know what they are doing.
As a Christian I would try to harmonize scientific findings with my Bible, and whenever my Bible said something other than the results of science in those rare areas where they disagreed, I would defer to my Bible. But things changed at that point. Now, with the results of science firmly in mind, I approached my Bible differently. I began deferring to science. My task changed. Now it was reversed. Knowing, as I did, that the universe was as old as science says it is, I went to my Bible and tried to harmonize it with this new knowledge—that made all the difference to me.
This was the first time I really considered the theological implications of the age of the universe. Two corollaries of that idea started me down the road to being the atheist I am today. The first is that in Genesis chapter 1 we see that the earth existed before the sun, moon, and stars, which were all created on the fourth day. This doesn’t square with astronomy. So I began looking at the first few chapters in Genesis, and as my thinking developed over time, I came to the conclusion that those chapters are folk literature—myth—something I’ll argue in a later chapter of this book. The second corollary for me at that time was this: If God took so long to create the universe, then why would he all of a sudden snap his fingers, so to speak, and create human beings? If God took his time to create the universe, then why wouldn’t he also create living creatures during the same length of time? Why did God take longer to create the stuff of the universe, which is less valuable and presumably less complex to create, than he did to create the most valuable and highly complex creatures to inhabit the earth? Astronomy describes the long process of galaxy, star, and planet formation. It then becomes uncharacteristic of God to create life on planet earth by divine fiat instantaneously. I concluded that God created human beings by the same long evolutionary process as he created the universe as a whole, if he created us at all.
Nearly two years afterward I came to deny the Christian faith. It required too much intellectual gerrymandering to believe. There were just too many individual problems that I had to balance, like spinning several plates up on several sticks, in order to keep my faith. At some point they just all came crashing down. This book presents the fullest explanation of my reasons for rejecting that faith.
THE CHURCH OF CHRIST
At this point, I want to describe why I left the Church of Christ in my area. The Angola Christian Church asked for my resignation in December 1990. It had nothing much at all to do with my affair with Linda, although some thought I was getting too close to her, and they wondered. I had offended John and Sybil Love, camp managers with Lake James Christian Assembly, in Angola, Indiana. They are decent, hardworking Christian people. They were opposed to my ministry for various petty reasons, in my opinion. So they left our church and started attending the Pleasant View Christian Church, also located in the small town of Angola. This was a church that had split off from ours a few decades back. Since they had relatives and friends in our church, the pressure was on to get them back, and the church elders felt that one way to get them back was to ask for my resignation. So they did. It’s not uncommon for ministers to be asked to leave a church when their effectiveness is gone. At the time, I argued that doing so would not bring the Loves back, and they didn’t go back, as I predicted.
We didn’t feel comfortable in attending a church from which I had resigned, so our family attended the Pleasant View Christian Church a couple of times. We sensed from the church leadership that they didn’t want us attending there, either, probably because that’s where the Loves began attending. At this point, neither one of the closest Christian Churches in our area wanted me.
What bothered me was that Jerry Paul, my ordaining minister, didn’t call me. Somehow I couldn’t call him either. I was just too embarrassed. But I needed to hear from him, and I’ve concluded he just didn’t want to get involved. A minister friend named George Faull told me that the Linda I mentioned earlier had called Jerry Paul to tell him that I had raped her, and so on. She was hell-bent on destroying me, is all I can figure. But Jerry never called me to talk, or pray with me, or comfort me. When George told me that Jerry had heard from her, my heart just sank. Why? Is this what successful ministers do? They avoid getting involved with people who have become “hot potatoes”? Did he care? Was I just a black mark on his list of accomplishments such that he wanted to avoid me? That’s how I felt. I really don’t know his reasons. Maybe he thought that if I wanted help all I had to do was call, and he’d be right there with me all of the way. That’s a nice way to do ministry, isn’t it? Maybe that’s just how he is, and maybe I could’ve gotten the encouragement I needed. But at the time, I felt rejected by someone I had respected the most.
After a while, I found myself teaching classes at Great Lakes Christian College (GLCC). My brother-in-law at the time, Tom Spoors, became the head of the Leadership Institute. It was a degree-completion program that GLCC set up and ran for a few years from about 1992 to1996. I taught philosophy and apologetic classes there. Shortly after beginning to teach at GLCC, Jerry Paul became the president of the college, but we never spoke about anything except those things related to my classes. Neither of us brought up the past.
Partly because I felt the Church of Christ leadership in my local area had rejected me, but also because I tend to stretch people’s minds anyway, I wrote a controversial essay on Christian baptism for Integrity magazine.6 The editorial board of Integrity included the late Dr. Brant Lee Doty and Curtis Lloyd. Both men had been acting presidents for GLCC in the past, and both were well-respected Church of Christ people. The board said it was “thoughtful and worthy of being printed in the interests of a dialogue about the subject.” The reaction, however, was intense. Sherman Nichols preached at a men’s meeting in the heart of Michigan and denounced that article, and me. This put the pressure on President Jerry Paul and Tom Spoors to relieve me of my teaching responsibilities at the college. They did. Jerry said that many people previously had reservations about my teaching for the college and that this was the last straw, although Jerry also said he couldn’t exactly pinpoint whether or not those reservations were legitimate ones. So I did the only thing I knew to do. I fired back in print with a second article on Christian baptism for Integrity.7 One minister friend said that this second article was “superb,” and another writer said that he didn’t think my baptism articles could be refuted. At that point, I was done with the Church of Christ.
Several other people did encourage me at that time, including a few Bible College professors. I’m the sort of person who has a very hard time asking for help, and I was hurting badly. Even so, Curtis Lloyd, Virgil Warren, John Castelein, and George Faull all encouraged me in various ways, and I was grateful for that.
You’ll notice that although I taught at GLCC and was still involved in various churches, my doubts were growing in intensity. I continued in the church because I didn’t yet know where my doubts would lead me. But when GLCC cut me off from its oversight and approval, I no longer had anything to lose by expressing my doubts, especially when my livelihood no longer depended on what I believed. I wonder how many other Christian professors and pastors are out there who, if they were cut off from the oversight and approval of their colleges and churches, would slide into disbelief as I did. In any case, my doubts took over at that point, especially after I experienced problems with my cousin Jeff at his church, a month or two later.
JEFF
The previously mentioned correspondence with my cousin Larry over evolution and the age of the universe took place while I was trying to maintain my faith in the Pleasant Lake Baptist Church. As I explained, I felt rejected by the Church of Christ in my local area. After my experience with Linda, I didn’t even go to church for several months. Meanwhile, another cousin of mine, Jeff, had become the pastor there, and I said to myself, “Here is a safe place to worship where I won’t get hurt.” So I gradually got involved. I helped wherever I could, and our family liked it very much. I taught Sunday school, preached on occasion, and eventually became an elder in that church with people who loved me and whom I loved, and I still do.
As best as I can tell, Jeff was suspicious of my motives—my own cousin! Without going into great detail, he and his wife, Lurleen (now Lauren), suspected that I was secretly trying to oust him to become the pastor there. I’m sure they felt threatened, but I didn’t mean to threaten them. The farthest thing from my mind was to oust him so that I could become the new pastor. I just wanted to help. Soon thereafter, he left the church and blamed me in a blistering last sermon that had my name all over it. An elder even asked me in an elder’s meeting after Jeff left if I would consider being the new pastor, and I turned it down. I really didn’t want to do it at all.
I have no ill feelings toward Jeff and his wife and I wish them well. After all, we are just people, and people sometimes feel this way. I still consider them my friends. But the thing about this experience was that I had to wrestle with the question of why someone who is as close to me as a cousin could misread my intentions so badly. How could he get it so wrong? And he was wrong. From this I began to reflect on the many different interpretations people have of the Bible, and I began to ask whether it’s possible to have a correct understanding of the Bible if people as close to each other as he and I could have such a misunderstanding. I began to doubt that people with our passions and living in our day and age, so removed from the Bible, could properly understand that book when people living in the same age and as close to one another as he and I couldn’t understand each other.
This last thought hit home extremely hard after Jeff left the church. In his wake, he left a rift in that church between a few important people who liked me and a few who didn’t. Soon after Jeff left the church, a problem developed between Mark, an elder, and Conny, the director of the children’s program. Mark didn’t like Conny, or her husband, or me, and he blamed us for Jeff leaving the church. I thought a lot of Conny, but she had a problem with her temper and got into a confrontation with Mark. She made a child sit out from an activity because he was unruly, but Mark told the child to participate anyway, and he did so in front of her! Well, she blew up at him on the spot. While it’s true she reacted badly, I thought Mark was unjustified in undermining her authority in front of the kids.
Afterward, a debate ensued among the elders of our church of which I was one. In the first place, I disagreed totally with how they wanted to handle the problem. I argued from the Bible that the two people who had the problem should sit down and talk about it first, but few agreed with me on that point. Beyond that, there were a few elders on one side who wanted to discipline (or punish) Conny by removing her from her position, and there were a few elders on the other side, including me, who wanted to forgive her. The interesting thing is that both sides claimed they were motivated by love. We all had our Bible verses to back it up, too! Apparently how believers appeal to the Bible depends on what they want to see happen for other reasons. The Bible tells us to love one another but it doesn’t tell us how to show our love, or who we should love more—in this case, Conny or Mark. Once again, the thought occurred to me how people living in the same day and age in the same church could have different understandings of what the Bible wanted us to do. I left that church over it, and so did most all of the people involved.
It sometimes still surprises me what people who are of the Christian faith will do with what they consider a clear conscience. I wonder to myself how these Christian consciences can differ so widely, especially when Christianity is the only faith whose believers claim God the Holy Spirit actually takes up residence in their being. I often ask myself why Christians don’t seem to act any better than others when they alone claim to have the power, wisdom, and guidance of God right there within them. Christians will claim that their faith doesn’t make them better than others, only that it makes them better than they would’ve been without it. But that seems like a cop-out to me now. If the Holy Spirit is uniquely living inside Christians, offering them divine wisdom and the power to obey, then there should be some evidence that they are at least minimally better people than non-Christians who do not have the Holy Spirit living inside them. In any case, the Holy Spirit didn’t properly do his job here. This was the last blow to my faith and one of the reasons why I am an atheist today.
By then the damage was done both psychologically in my experiences and intellectually as I continued to study the issues. Massive doubt crept upon me until I didn’t want to be a part of any church much at all.
My Divorce
Finally, I decided I wasn’t going to live out the rest of my life not being happily married. So I left Kathy and decided I was going to look for love again. I did feel guilty for this, but neither of us was happy in our marriage. Pollster George Barna’s research has shown that “a surprising number of Christians experienced divorces both before and after their conversion.”8 Why should it be different for skeptics when they leave their religion? To a large extent, because of my divorce, I stayed away from churches. The longer I was away, the less I believed, and the less I believed, the less I wanted to attend church.
In the era of tell-all books, I think honesty is what’s required so that readers can see and judge for themselves about the totality of the reasons why I rejected Christianity. I don’t believe conversion or deconversion experiences take place strictly because of epistemic reasons in either direction, in most cases. There are almost always social and psychological factors too. Anyone who regularly hears Christian conversion stories knows exactly what I mean. All of the ones I’ve ever personally heard had to do to some degree with someone who has either grown up in the church or someone who has had some dramatic experience when down on his or her luck. If anyone wants to discount my deconversion and present rejection of Christianity because of my experiences, then I could discount the overwhelming number of Christian conversion experiences owing to similar factors like divorce, bankruptcy, jail, addiction, and so forth. Anyone intelligent enough to realize that these factors influence us all will wonder what these factors were for me, so I have spelled them out here in both my conversion and my deconversion stories. I share these experiences in the attempt to show that my rejection of Christianity is sincere and honest.
After reading my deconversion story, Norman L. Geisler e-mailed me:
I have just read your book and my heart goes out to you. I think many people would have become atheists, had they gone through what you have. First, I would like to apologize on behalf of the body of Christ for the unloving way in which you were treated. My sympathy is with you. I am so sorry. I wish I knew you better and lived close enough to give you a hug. Just let me say, I love you regardless of what has happened. The legalistic, unkind, and hypocritical way you were treated was simply unchristian and uncalled for. Again, I apologize on behalf of anyone involved who professes the name of Christ. I will be recommending your book to our students. There are many things Christians can learn from it, not the least of which is what Jesus said in John 13:35. Of course, I do not agree with your conclusions, but there is no justification for unloving behavior on the part of Christians.
I don’t need any sympathy at this point, and I especially don’t want any pity. I very much appreciate Norm’s concern and compassion though. On a personal level he’s a gracious man whom I consider a friend, but with this recognition comes the next question: Why didn’t God do something to avert these particular experiences of mine, especially if he could foreknow that I would eventually write this book and lead others astray?
Additional Thoughts
I know many Christians who refuse to deal with the arguments later on in this book will use the personal information I’ve just shared to attack my character. No doubt you’ll hear that I am an adulterer, something that took place twenty years ago as of this writing, and that I’m divorced. The truth is I am a flawed human being. I’ll be the first one to admit it. However, as a counselor in all of the churches I’ve served, I learned that every single one of us is a flawed human being. It’s precisely because I realize this that I can be honest about myself and about my flaws. And this is freeing to me. I can be honest about who I am and what I’ve done. Christians are in denial and live with guilt because they cannot be honest about themselves outside of the private counseling room. I personally know the kind of behavior that leaders in every church I served admitted to doing. I suspect that the Christians throwing stones at me are no different than the church people whom I counseled—flawed just like them.
Many Christians will also discount my deconversion due to my sin. Their claim is that the whole reason I no longer believe isn’t because of the arguments, because they think the arguments on behalf of Christianity are solid. They will assume that I left the faith because of my own personal failures, and they will use this to discount everything else in this book. James Spiegel argues from the Bible that atheists simply have a will to disbelieve, that “atheists ultimately choose not to believe in God.”9 Although I find this claim very interesting, it’s dead wrong. The truth is that my personal experiences forced me to do what I should have been doing all along, critically examining my faith. It took these experiences because the power of the delusion is that strong. So just because many of us leave the faith after some bad experiences, it does not follow that the experiences alone caused us to leave the faith. The bad experiences merely caused us to wake from our dogmatic slumbers. They forced us into actually thinking critically about our inherited faith for probably the first time in our lives.
While the things I have just written might explain to some degree why my thinking has changed, I want to stress the fact that my thinking has indeed changed. You cannot explain away my present thinking by pointing to the experiences I’ve had in my life. If we accept such a standard for argumentation, then we can reject any argument based upon how the proponent lives his or her life—clearly an ad hominem attack. In considering what I have written, you will have to deal with my arguments. People believe and doubt for a wide variety of reasons, and that’s all there is to it.
It wasn’t just my affair with Linda that led me to reject Christianity anyway. I could have gotten beyond the damage that the affair had done to my faith. It was being cut off from the church in the wake of the affair that made my faith vulnerable to the new way of seeing things that I had learned from my cousin Larry. These events combined to set me on a course of doubt, and with the addition of the subsequent church experiences I had while teaching at GLCC and in my cousin Jeff’s church, I eventually came to reject my former faith. I just couldn’t reconcile everything I had experienced and everything that I had learned with the Christian faith. Even though I approached Christianity from the presumption of faith, my experiences and my studies ended my faith. I determined that in the end the skeptics were right all along.
My doubts had been simmering for a few years but I didn’t think much about them. When Mel Gibson’s movie The Passion of the Christ came out in 2004, it made me think about them again, intensely. More than anything else this movie put me on a course to finally come out of the closet and tell the world what I think, for I saw in that movie such an ignorance that I just had to speak out. I will have more to say about this in chapter 20.
I tried the best I could to be a faithful Christian and a good minister. Even though I believed it was by grace that I had been saved, I almost always felt guilty that I wasn’t doing enough in response to God’s purported love. This was something I fully understood only after walking away from the Christian faith. Whether it was spending time in prayer, evangelizing, reading the Bible, tithing, forgiving, or struggling with temptations of lust, pride, selfishness, and laziness, as I look back, I almost always felt guilty. It may just be because I was so passionate about Christianity that this was the case, and so it just might be my particular temperament. I never could understand how Christian people could come to church every Sunday but never get involved much in the church’s programs, because that’s what believers should want to do. To be quite frank here, if Christians really believed that God saved them through Jesus and that the non-Christian was going to hell, then how would they behave? How many true believers are in the churches today?
Today I am guilt-free regarding the Christian duties mentioned above. I am so grateful for my present life because I’m living life to the hilt. I just don’t think anyone can live a passionate guilt-free Christian life. Think about it; according to Jesus, I should feel guilty for not just what I do but for what I think about—lusting, hating, coveting, and so on. I’d like every person who reads this book to experience the freedom I have found.
I think a former member of my blog named exbeliever best described how I feel about this whole matter:
For a long time, I was an ardent admirer of Dr. John Piper. I remember a sermon of Dr. Piper’s in which he described God as a flowing fountain of delight. The Psalmist writes, “Taste and see that the LORD is good; blessed is the man who takes refuge in him” (Psalm 34:8). Piper said that we would praise a fountain, not by standing passively by, but by sticking our faces deep inside it to take in its wonderful refreshment. We would stand up and shout, “This is the best water I’ve ever tasted; come and have some with me!” He invited others to taste and see God’s goodness.
But what about those of us who have left the fountain with a horrible taste in our mouths? We came to the fountain and drank as deeply as we could and, for a while, could not get enough of it. We loved reading the Bible and being instructed by it. We believed that it made us wiser than our counselors. We made our bodies our slaves so that they would honor God. We prayed without ceasing. We sought first the kingdom of God. We confessed our sins and believed that God was faithful and just to forgive us our sins. We preached “the Word” in season and out. We attempted to study to show ourselves approved. We fed God’s sheep.
But, then, something happened. The fountain became foul to us. We tried to ignore the taste. We went back to it again and again hoping something would change. We opened the Bible and, instead of finding wisdom, we found violence and the justification of immoral acts. We found anti-intellectualism and backward thinking. We found oppression. Our prayers returned to us void. They bounced off of the ceiling. We prayed harder and felt dumber for it. While we could still enjoy the fellowship of Christian people, we discovered that what we liked about them had nothing to do with their Christianity, but rather with their humanity. We found that we simply liked the people for who they were, not because they believed something about a religion.
We weren’t trying to “leave the faith.” The faith was leaving us. We tried to hold on to the fountain, but something had changed. It wasn’t the fountain; it was our taste for it. We realized that the fountain wasn’t a being; it was a religion. It was just dogma. It is like we had been drinking from it with our eyes closed and noses plugged. Somehow, though, we opened our eyes and unplugged our noses and discovered that we had been enjoying filth. The fountain was a fountain of blood and other foul things. We realized that we had spent most of our lives consuming a vile concoction.
We would have been happy to have simply left, but we couldn’t help but want to pull others away from such a cesspool. We wanted to help them open their eyes and see what we saw. We wanted them to see the trouble the fountain was causing in the world. Quickly, however, we ran into opposition. We found that those still slurping away at the fountain with eyes closed and noses plugged resisted. They said that we were lying about the taste of the fountain or that we had never drunk from it in the first place. We told them to open their eyes, but they responded that the eyes cannot be trusted. We described the filth to them, but even when they accepted that the fountain contained blood and other “foul” things, they insisted that those things were really “good.”
With my personal story out on the table it’s time to begin. As I have said, I can only wish that Christian apologists would share their stories with the same level of honesty. In response to stories by people like me, several of them, like Lee Strobel and David Wood, are now claiming that they were former atheists who converted to Christianity. I’d like to know what kind of atheists they were. Most of them were practical atheists and nothing more, people who lived as though God did not exist. But that describes most of us, even many believers. If they would tell us their stories honestly I’ll bet only a few rare converts were intellectual atheists with higher-level philosophical and scientific degrees. Of those degreed people who converted to Christianity, I would be surprised if any of them subsequently became card-carrying, inerrant, six-day creationist evangelicals.
--------------
Chapter 1 Endnotes:
1. Thomas V. Morris, Francis Schaeffer’s Apologetics: A Critique (Chicago: Moody Press, 1976).
2. See The Jury Is In: The Ruling on McDowell’s “Evidence,” an online book edited by Secular Web founder Jeffery Jay Lowder, at http://www.infidels.org.
3. See John Beversluis, C. S. Lewis and the Search for Rational Religion (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1985), which has been revised and published with the same title through Prometheus Books in 2007. I wrote a review of this book here: https://www.debunking-christianity.com/search?q=beversluis. Beverskuis wrote a series of chapters in critique of Christianity, which after he died his widow granted me permission to publish: https://www.debunking-christianity.com/2021/06/john-beversluis-has-died-at-age-of-86.html
4. John W. Loftus, “A Christian Defense of the Gospel in a Twentieth Century Land,” Christian Standard, September 19, 1982.
5. Richard Taylor, Having Love Affairs (Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books, 1982), as quoted in Brooke Noel Moore and Robert Michael Stewart, Moral Philosophy: A Comprehensive Introduction (Mountain View, CA: Mayfield, 1994), p. 570.
6. John W. Loftus, “Is Baptism Necessary for Salvation,” Integrity, July/August 1995.
7. John W. Loftus, “Is Baptism Necessary—One More Time,” Integrity, January/February 1996. Both of these articles can be found on my blog. Just do a search on it for “Is Baptism Necessary for Salvation?” https://www.debunking-christianity.com/2006/10/is-baptism-necessary-for-salvation.html
8. Barna Group, “Born Again Christians Just as Likely to Divorce as Are Non-Christians,” September 8, 2004, http:// http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/5-barna-update/194-born-again-christians-just-as-likely-to-divorce-as-are-non-christians (accessed November 15, 2011).
9. James S. Spiegel, The Making of an Atheist: How Immorality Leads to Unbelief (Chicago: Moody, 2010), p. 86.
No comments:
Post a Comment