My Stepfather John Died Friday

I arrived in Reno, Nevada, to see John (his name) two hours before he died. He looked comfortable until the end. They said he waited until I arrived to hear my voice and that with no blood pressure he shouldn't have survived Thursday night. It was bittersweet. I'm now helping my Mom work through her grief along with some legal and funeral decisions. My brothers both live out here, one in Reno and another in Sacramento, CA, so she'll be in good hands. John's remains are going to be cremated, just like my Dad was, and just as I plan on being. Below is a rough draft of what I plan on saying during the memorial planned at his Presbyterian Church later this week.

[Edited upon further reflection Monday]

John and I shared similar beliefs. I am a former preacher who is now an atheist. When I had first accepted evolution more than a decade ago, John's eyes lit up. He went on and on about how ignorant is it not to accept it. On occasion John even told my Mom that the Bible "is all a bunch of fairy tales." We agreed on that. He did believe in some kind of god though, and found it comfortable worshipping that god in this church.

Polls say that nonbelievers make up the second largest denomination in America, behind Catholicism. So there might be people here besides myself who have to memorialize the dead where we must listen to Christians express things we just cannot accept. But let it be known that John, like my father before him, and like me after them both, will all end up in the same place that animals go to when they die. In the ground. Therefore the pain of losing a loved one is more intense for us. We have no false comfort of divine strength in times of loss, nor do we have any false hope of seeing our loved ones again. All we can do is be thankful our paths crossed and we made the journey lighter for each other, and John did that with me. And he was very good for my Mom. I'll never forget him, and that's all I can say, for I'll never see him again. I'll miss him greatly.

54 comments:

James F. McGrath said...

John, please accept my condolences.

Mike D said...

Sorry to hear it John. My condolences.

Rob R said...

My condolences to you John during this time. At least you got to say goodbye.

Anonymous said...

Hello,

I'm sorry for your loss. I wonder, however. Should you really be that polarizing in the speech?

Shane said...

John, deep condolences to you and your family. My son (7) asked me the other day where heaven was. I told him that heaven wasn't a *place*, but the situation where people remember good things about you after you've died. That is a real heaven - you live on in people's thoughts and in their love. No need for fairy stories or angels or streets of gold. From the Universe we have come; to the Universe we return. Like many atheists, I find that uplifting and glorious - even our tiniest actions will eventually change history (for good or ill), but the echoes of our presence will be felt, essentially for ever, at least if anything about chaos theory is correct. So death is less about closing the curtain than about handing on the baton.

I'm thinking of writing a little about this for the Church of Jesus Christ Atheist (not to everyone's taste, I acknowledge). But best wishes to you and your family.

Harry H. McCall said...

I’m very sorry to here about your step-dad, John. You have my condolences.

After I read your thoughts on the life of your step-ad, I was reminded of the closing paragraph in Ed Babinski’s book Leaving the Fold: Testimonies of Former Fundamentalist under the section on Atheists by the late Howard M. Teeple quoted from his own book: I Started to be a Minister:

When I was seven my chief playmate, Ted, a beautiful white collie dog, died of old age. Father hitched our horse Dolly to a sled, loaded Ted’s body on it, and drove half a mile down into the river-bottom portion of our farm. There, in sandy soil under three Douglas fir trees, we buried Ted, with my tears. Father simply said, “You were a good dog, Ted; we’ll miss you.” Best funeral I ever attended - no theological nonsense, just love.

I could not agree more!!

Anonymous said...

I am very sorry to hear that, John, but glad you got there. I have checked every day since your original post for an update. Grieving is hard and I hope your family will draw strength from each other. I hope you don't mind if I pray for you all. It can't hurt, right? ;-)

Dan

Anthony said...

John, you have my condolences.

Chuck said...

Sorry buddy.

Be good to yourself.

Peace.

Tony Hoffman said...

I am glad you have the courage to speak these words at an event and in a place like this. I've been to funerals where the minister transparently demanded the family (and those present) accept his every word or they would never see the deceased again. It played like a hostage taker making demands, and it was all the more unseemly as it preyed on those so vulnerable. Church funerals can sometimes be unbearable affairs for me, and the thought of someone delivering words like this, somewhere, is gratifying.

normajean said...

I'm terribly sorry, John.

Al Moritz said...

My condolences, John to you and your family.

I agree with Magnumdb, your speech might not be a good place to be that polarizing. You'll not convert anyone on such an occasion, and might just hurt feelings.

Christian Agnostic said...

My condolences John, at this sad time but why use the moment as a platform for your non-belief when a simple heart-felt tribute would surely suffice? If the service was at a humanist gathering and a family member used the moment to proclaim the gospel it would not go down well...

shane said...

John.

Apparently i've already said something here (must be another shane although i've never seen one) anyway im sorry for your loss, keep your chin up!

goprairie said...

Sorry to hear about the loss of your 'second father'. Remember the wise words of Dr. Seuss when thinking about this man's life:
"Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened."
People invented funerals for a reason: To comfort each other. We need to figure out our own ways to do that, sort of an atheist comfort-while-greiving vocabulary.

BJ said...

John, I'm very sorry for your loss.

Anonymous said...

I edited this today upon further reflection. It seems I was writing this for my Blog rather than for the actual memorial service.

Thanks everyone.

Anonymous said...

There isn't much to say, except that you and your family are on my mind and heart. I encourage you to speak your heart and mind.
--Justin

Evan said...

John, best wishes to you and your whole family.

Piratefish said...

Miss him greatly indeed, and let this be your future strength. Best wishes for you and your family.

Anonymous said...

John, I'm sorry for your loss.

District Supt. Harvey Burnett said...

My condolences John. Hope all is well for you and the remaining family.

Take care.

Byroniac said...

John Loftus,

Sorry for your loss because I know it has to hurt, and I hope you can find comfort in the middle of your grief.

Breckmin said...

John,
I am extremely sorry for your loss.
-Michael

Joe E. Holman said...

So sorry, John. Take some time and tend to the family, old buddy.

(JH)

christophermencken said...

John, I was sorry to hear about your stepfather's death. I appreciate deeply that you're sharing your thoughts to be spoken at the memorial. They're thoughtful, deep, your unique voice, and boy it's from your heart. That's lovely and perfect. Your family and this world needs thinkers like you. Take care.

Charity said...

John,
I know you don't know me from anyone, but I've been reading your blog for several months now. In a distant way, you feel like a friend. Losing people does seem more intense knowing they are simply gone. They no longer exist in body or "spirit." I've experienced several losses in the past couple of years. I'm sorry to hear of your loss. I hope you take care of yourself and are surrounded by people who love you as you grieve.
Charity

Russ said...

All the best for you and your family, John.

Unknown said...

Sorry for your loss.

Dr. Hector Avalos said...

John,
I've been away for a few days, but please know that Cindy and I are very sorry for your loss. Our best wishes to you and your family.

Unknown said...

My condolences to you and all your family John at this difficult time.

Although we've never met and onle corresponded a couple of times, i've been addicted ( maybe to my detriment :) ) to your DC blog for many years now.

I know it seems some tempting to keep posting here, but why not take a good break now from it and let that "caretaker" chap look after this blog for a while.

We wont go away. We'll still "be here" when you come back :)

Is there an address to send flowers etc to ? (maybe a friend of yours )

Take care mate. Your work is not in vain.

Regards,

Dan S.

Jeff Eyges said...

John, my condolences as well.

Angie Van De Merwe said...

Your step-dad must have thought a lot of you, too, as he waited for you, so he could go 'in peace; knowing he had given you a "good bye". That is love. I am sorry that we have to live with loss.

Glenn said...

John, I'm really sorry for your loss.

Anonymous said...

I shared what I wanted to say at the memorial with my Mom, and she does not want me to say this. She's embarrassed that I'm an atheist. This intensifies my grief. Okay. She's my Mom. I won't say anything. I've been silenced.

Anonymous said...

John W. Loftus said...
I shared what I wanted to say at the memorial with my Mom, and she does not want me to say this. She's embarrassed that I'm an atheist. This intensifies my grief. Okay. She's my Mom. I won't say anything. I've been silenced.


Your mother is wise. Your "speech" would have made a lot of people uncomfortable, and for what purpose?

God(s)/Spirit(s)/Nature/Reason/Whatever bless your mother.

Al Moritz said...

Your mother is wise. Your "speech" would have made a lot of people uncomfortable, and for what purpose?

Exactly. Like I said, you'll not convert anyone on such an occasion, and you might just hurt feelings. There is a time for such things, but this is not the time.

Anthony said...

Al: Like I said, you'll not convert anyone on such an occasion, and you might just hurt feelings. There is a time for such things, but this is not the time.

Al, I understand your point, but what is frustrating for people like John and myself is that when we are attending something like a memorial or a funeral religion is almost always brought up and even emphasized.

Unknown said...

Although a fellow non-believer, I must say that I find your speech inappropriately preachy. You complain about being preached at by Christians at other people's funerals and yet you want to do the same yourself.

People know who you are and what you stand for. Talk about John and your what he meant to you and not about yourself and your beliefs.

Anonymous said...

Al, I understand your point, but what is frustrating for people like John and myself is that when we are attending something like a memorial or a funeral religion is almost always brought up and even emphasized.

Then... don't go.

Or find a reason to go to the restroom when the "preaching/religion" part starts. :)

Chuck said...

John,

Grief is strange.

I think it is a good thing you wrote out your feelings.

You now have a ready answer when some pretentious religionist wants to frame your step-dad's death with their superstition.

I like it.

christophermencken said...

re: your mom. Just hang in there, John.

goprairie said...

John
Regarding your mom, respect is in order, but it is a two-way street. She needs to cut you a little slack too.
Back when you were a conservative Christian, you would not have preached your version at a Lutheran funeral. However, if someone had said something directly to you, you might have felt free to declare a simple summary of your beliefs. Atheism should be no different, eh? No need to put it in their face, butno need to hide either.
If you are going to speak, and you should be allowed to, you can tell stories about him and you CAN mention if it is relevant that you shared a casualness about religion and that you felt respect from him in your minority status as an atheist, if that was important to your relationship with him. It should be about your relationship to him, about him as a person, about what he meant to you. Your atheism should only be part of the talk if it fits into those parameters? You can make those claims about how it fit into your relationship with him without telling them their stuff is nonsense.
But if they tell you they are going to pray for him, you can say 'He'd probably rather you remember him kindly and tell good stories about him and nurture in yourself the things you admired about him."
And if they offer to pray for you, you can feel free to say "I don't beleive in God, so please don't. I'd rather you spend time remembering my step-dad and talking to people about his good traits." Or something like that.
A funeral is a time to comfort and be comforted. So I'd not deliberately take stands that might cause hurt, but when people are in YOUR face about it, you can also expect some understanding and comfort and not have to edit your thoughts or repress your feelings. Moderation, I think, is the key?
My in-laws made me go to a New Year's Eve catholic service, and I was good. Mostly.
You can do it. It's not either-or, it's compromise.

James Pate said...

My condolences, John. It's good you got to say good bye.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Grace said...

(((John))) I'm so sorry about your stepdad, and sorrowing that your grief has been intensified.

I don't understand your strong drive to share atheism, but my heart aches with you.

Deep peace fill you.

Anonymous said...

BO HO BO HO BO HO BO HO!
MY STEPDADDY DIED & I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO! I BELIEVE HE DESCENDED FROM AN APE, SO MAYBE HE IS GONE BACK TO THE PLANET OF THE APES???
WHAT DO YOU MONKEYS, ORANGUTANS & APES THINK???

Grace said...

Leonardo,

I can't believe the unkindness of your post. What are you thinking here??

Suppose this was your father?

You owe John an apology.

Unknown said...

@Grace. Absolutely - this leonardo chap what appears to be his own pro-catholic christian blog.

Fine example he sets.

Of course nastiness like this kind of trolling happens on both sides - but the fact this guy blogs in "defence" of his xtianity and then does this is just shameful.

Anonymous said...

YO COCKSUCKERS,

You boast about evolution & make a mockery of spiritual & Christian things, so what's the problem if I call a spade a spade & a piece of SHIT a piece of SHIT.

As George Carlin (one of you) would say; You motherfucker, cocksucking piece of shit can go kiss my ass!

John, "Wheresmystepdaddygone" go & do likewise.

ALL TOGETHER NOW: BO HO BO HO BO HO, we all love you John.

Grace said...

Leonardo,

Scripture for your meditation.

Prayers of Celebration

If I speak in the tongues of men and angels, but have not love,
I have become sounding brass or a tinkling cymbal.

And if I have prophecy and know all mysteries and
all knowledge, and if I have all faith so as to remove mountains,
but have not love, I am nothing.

And if I dole out all my goods, and
if I deliver my body that I may boast
but have not love, nothing I am profited.

Love is long suffering,
love is kind,
it is not jealous,
love does not boast,
it is not inflated.

It is not discourteous,
it is not selfish,
it is not irritable,
it does not enumerate the evil.

It does not rejoice over the wrong,
but rejoices in the truth

It covers all things, it has faith for all things,
it hopes in all things, it endures in all things.

Love never falls in ruins;
but whether prophecies, they will be abolished; or
tongues, they will cease; or
knowledge, it will be superseded.

For we know in part and we prophecy in part.

But when the perfect comes, the imperfect will be superseded.

When I was an infant,
I spoke as an infant, I reckoned as an infant;
when I became [an adult],
I abolished the things of the infant.

For now we see through a mirror in an enigma, but then face to face.
Now I know in part, but then I shall know
as also I was fully known.

But now remains faith, hope, love, these three;
but the greatest of these is love.

1 Corinthians 13:1-13

Anonymous said...

Its AMAZING Grace, how ignorant you are of the CONTEXT of Scripture:

John Loftus & his kind are called DOGS & SOWS by the Apostle Peter & you might like to read Matthew 23 to see what Jesus of Nazareth thought of the Scribes & Pharisees.

Leonardo

Anonymous said...

I KNOW LOFTUS WOULD HAVE PREFERRED IT WAS HIS MOMMA "KICKED THE BUCKET" RATHER THAN HIS STEPDADDY. THAT OULD ONE HAS HAUNTED JOHN'S WHOLE LIFE.

"JOHNNNNNN, what are you doing now"? "JOHNNNNNN, I KNOW YOU ARE UP TO SOMETHING! WHY IS YOUR BEDROOM LOCKED??? John was inside having a WANK & to this day cannot understand how his momma knew when ever he was "chucking his cock."

She was an all knowing goddess.

Anonymous said...

Did you know that Martin Luther King Jr said, “I’M FUCKIN FOR GOD TONIGHT”!

In his book, “I May Not Get There Wirh You”, Michael Eric Dyson, an ordained Baptist minister, chapter 8, Dyson mentions Martin Luther King’s adulterous activity.

“To be fair, King’s habits of sexual adventure had been well established by the time he was married. His personal and public circumstances only amplified his sexual nindiscretions.” page 161

King is heard on the FBI tapes,

“Come on over here, you big black motherfucker, and let me suck your dick.”

The comment was directed towards Rev. Ralph Abernathy.