Phil Bair On Extraordinary Evidence For Miracles
Phil Bair was suggested by James K. Walker to debate me. Walker is a Christian apologist and former Mormon who is President at Watchman Fellowship. I hadn't heard of Phil before. But he seems smart enough. Anyone who has read my anthology on miracles and still disagrees gets my attention.
Phil offered two objections to my defense of the aphorism, "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence."
ONE) Phil Bair: “You have no criteria for identifying what qualifies as extraordinary evidence for an extraordinary claim.” My response: